|
September 8
The Founding Fathers were very concerned with government becoming too powerful and crushing fragile liberty. As you read excerpts from the
Federalist Papers championing a large republic
with distinct checks and balances as the most
sure protector of individual liberty consider
and react to one or both of the following
statements:
A. Separation
of powers has been an important part of democracy since the early Greek
City-States, and was a central feature of the Roman Republic.
George W. Bush and Dick Cheney have been doing their best to undo this
founding principle of democracy for some time. They object to any
congressional oversight of the executive branch, and have appointed
Supreme Court judges who believe in a strong executive. We all know the
endless stream of abuses which have taken place under the Bush White
House, many of them posing serious threats to civil liberties. And yet,
somehow, the basic building blocks of US democracy remain intact - barely. (source: Separation of Powers--Kerim Friedman)
B. The
premise behind the Separation of Powers is that when a single person or
group has a large amount of power, they can become dangerous to
citizens. The Separation of Power is a method of removing the amount of
power in any group's hands, making it more difficult to abuse.
The US
government has a partial Separation of Powers. It distinguishes between
three groups. The Executive, the Legislative, and the Judicial. They
are distinguished by the kind of power they wield. The Legislative
branch has the ability to enact laws. The Executive branch has the
ability to see those laws enforced. The Judicial branch has the ability
to decide the guilt of a party, allowing punishment.
If a
single group shared all three powers, they would have unlimited power.
They could specify any law, arresting the 'criminal', and then decide
that they are guilty. Through the Separation of Powers, though, no
group can have more than one of these powers. Only through the combined
use of all three can the government use force. By requiring the consent
of all three branches, it increases the likelihood that the government
will not initiate violent force. (source: Jeff Landower and Joseph Rowlands--Separation of Powers) |
|